Look no further! I have searched for one that I would love FOREVER and finally I have found it. I tried several different brands and most recently I tried Ulta brand.. and was severely disappointed! The weird sponge material that they (and a few other) eyeliner brands use dried up quick and left a very flaky mess on my eyes.
I really find it pointless to have an eyeliner that flakes off only minutes after putting it on. Not to mention that you get eyeliner pieces in your eyes. Eyeliner should never come off in pieces! Not only that the Ulta dried up in only a few days! I barely got a week out of it before it would not work anymore. Take note of that Ulta.. your eyeliner sucks. I recommend not even wasting your money on trying this brand. You will be disappointed.
So I went into Sephora looking for a liquid eyeliner that would actually work and the lady there recommended Lorac. Not the cheapest around with a price tag of $23... but I figured I would give it a try anyway.
It glides on smoothly and stays! It doesn't clump or run. It doesn't flake or peel. It STAYS! I love it! You can make the line as thin or thick as you like since Lorac uses a BRUSH instead of a sponge! I have found my brand and will stick with it unless I find something that works just as good if not better and cheaper!
So go check it out and give it a test at an Ulta or Sephora store near you.